8 red flags on a financial advisor's record
TL;DR. Most advisors have clean records. The ones that don't usually leave a pattern — multiple customer complaints with the same theme, fresh bankruptcy while managing client funds, short tenures at multiple firms, concurrent registration and termination events. These patterns are public on IAPD and FINRA BrokerCheck. The red flags below are the ones that consistently precede advisor misconduct cases.
Where to find the record
Every red flag below is visible on the advisor's public regulatory report on IAPD or BrokerCheck. If you haven't done the lookup yet, see How to verify an advisor's CRD number for the 3-minute walkthrough.
One note: any single red flag in isolation is not a disqualifier. A 20-year career includes bumps. The pattern — two or more red flags, or one very serious one — is what matters.
Red flag #1: Multiple settled customer complaints with the same theme
What to look for: Two or more customer arbitration complaints or disputes, especially when they share a theme (unsuitable recommendations, excessive trading, unauthorized transactions).
Why it's a red flag: Settled complaints aren't automatic guilt. But a pattern of settlements for the same type of dispute — especially when the settlement amounts are material — suggests behavior that was repeated across clients. Three settled complaints of "unsuitable recommendations" across ten years of practice is very different from one.
What to ask: "Can you walk me through what happened in each case, and what changed in your practice afterward?"
Red flag #2: Terminations "for cause"
What to look for: A BrokerCheck event labeled "Termination — Discharged" or "Termination — Permitted to Resign" connected to a customer complaint.
Why it's a red flag: Firms fire advisors for cause when they can no longer defend keeping them. Many terminated advisors re-register at a different firm within 30 days. Pay attention to the reason given — "violation of firm policy," "failure to follow procedures," or "customer complaint" are all serious.
What to ask: "The record shows you were terminated at [firm] in [year]. What happened?" You want a specific story, not a sentence.
Red flag #3: Recent personal bankruptcy while managing client funds
What to look for: Personal bankruptcy filings within the past 10 years, disclosed on Form ADV Part 2B Item 3 or BrokerCheck.
Why it's a red flag: Bankruptcy in itself isn't disqualifying — life happens. But a cash-strapped advisor faces financial pressure that can conflict with client interest. If the bankruptcy was during the time they were managing client money, ask questions.
What to ask: "I saw the bankruptcy disclosure. Was that related to any business decisions that affected clients?"
Red flag #4: Five or more firm changes in ten years
What to look for: A career jumping from firm to firm every 18–24 months, especially across different broker-dealers.
Why it's a red flag: Stable fiduciary advisors tend to stay at firms for years, or they start their own. Frequent moves — especially when clients are uprooted with each transition — can mean the advisor is searching for looser supervision or a higher payout deal. Sometimes it also means they're moving ahead of customer complaints.
What to ask: "Your record shows a lot of firm changes. What's the story?"
Red flag #5: Regulatory actions by the SEC, FINRA, or state regulators
What to look for: Any "Regulatory Event" disclosure. These are enforcement actions by the SEC, FINRA, state securities commissions, or other regulators.
Why it's a red flag: Regulators don't bring cases lightly. A resolved regulatory action — fine, censure, suspension — means the advisor did something their regulator decided deserved enforcement. A pattern of regulatory actions is disqualifying.
What to ask: "Walk me through the regulatory action. What was alleged, what was the outcome, and what changed afterward?"
Red flag #6: Criminal disclosures related to finance
What to look for: Criminal convictions, pleas, or indictments related to finance, fraud, theft, or dishonesty. These appear under the Disclosures tab.
Why it's a red flag: Obvious. Financial advisors with a finance-related criminal history should not be advising you on money. Non-finance criminal matters (a DUI in 1998) are a separate conversation.
What to ask: Nothing to ask. Walk away.
Red flag #7: Current status "Not Currently Registered"
What to look for: The summary at the top of the advisor's IAPD or BrokerCheck page reads "Not Currently Registered" or shows an end date in a recent past period.
Why it's a red flag: A person not currently registered cannot legally give you securities advice for compensation. If they're claiming to, they are either not registered where they're operating, or they're holding themselves out as something they're not.
What to ask: Do not hire. If they claim to be registered and the system says they aren't, verify by calling their firm's compliance department.
Red flag #8: Form ADV Part 2A Item 5 mentions "in addition to"
What to look for: Language in Item 5 (Fees and Compensation) like "in addition to our advisory fee," "may earn commissions," "other compensation," or a listed "additional sources of compensation" section.
Why it's a red flag: This is the structural signal that the firm is fee-based, not fee-only. The advisor has compensation incentives to recommend specific products over others — the exact conflict the fiduciary standard is designed to eliminate. Not a disqualifier on its own, but a signal you need to verify each recommendation against independent alternatives.
What to ask: "Item 5 mentions other compensation. What percentage of your revenue comes from those sources, and on which products?"
What to do with what you find
Run the record through this filter:
- Zero red flags, fee-only, long tenure at one or two firms, CFP® or equivalent credential → proceed with the interview.
- One mild red flag with a clear story (one old customer complaint, one short firm tenure) → proceed with eyes open. Ask the story.
- Two or more red flags, or one serious red flag (regulatory action, finance-related crime, recent "for cause" termination) → keep looking.
- Current "Not Currently Registered" status → do not hire. Report to the state regulator if they claim otherwise.
The pattern recognition that matters
A 2019 University of Chicago Booth study on advisor misconduct found that roughly 7% of U.S. financial advisors have a misconduct record, and that advisors with a prior misconduct event are five times more likely to engage in misconduct again. Past patterns predict future patterns.
The goal of reading the record isn't to find a perfect advisor — it's to make sure the one you hire isn't part of the 7% for whom misconduct is a repeat behavior.
Key takeaways
- Most advisors are clean. Patterns matter more than isolated events.
- The public record (IAPD + BrokerCheck) shows disclosures, terminations, regulatory actions, and bankruptcies.
- The most predictive signals: multiple same-theme complaints, regulatory actions, "for cause" terminations.
- Ask about every disclosure. How they tell the story is its own signal.
- A single red flag with a good story is often fine. Two or more — move on.
Sources
- SEC Investment Adviser Public Disclosure — adviserinfo.sec.gov.
- FINRA BrokerCheck — brokercheck.finra.org.
- Egan, Matvos, Seru, "The Market for Financial Adviser Misconduct," Journal of Political Economy, 2019. NBER preprint.
Start with advisors whose records are already clean.
Every Fiduciary Check advisor has been reviewed on IAPD and BrokerCheck against the same red-flag checklist above. Only clean-record, fee-only fiduciaries earn the Orange Check.
Find a verified fiduciary → · Verify an advisor →