Back to the blog
EducationalNovember 13, 202616 min read

Investment Management Is Not Financial Planning: Here Is the Difference

By: Alex Bridges, CFP®, EA, ChFC®, RICP®Investment Management Is Not Financial Planning: Here Is the DifferenceOne of the things I have noticed throughout my career as a financial planner is how often...

By Alex Bridges

Fiduciary Check
Partner

By: Alex Bridges, CFP®, EA, ChFC®, RICP®

Investment Management Is Not Financial Planning: Here Is the Difference

One of the things I have noticed throughout my career as a financial planner is how often people confuse investment management with financial planning. They have an advisor, their money is invested, and they receive regular statements showing how their accounts are performing. Naturally, they assume their financial planning is being taken care of, too.

Sometimes it is. There are plenty of financial advisors who provide investment management and comprehensive financial planning together. But I have also seen situations where someone has been paying for investment management for years without ever having a detailed conversation about how they will actually use that money in retirement.

That distinction becomes especially important for someone who has spent 30 years saving in a 401(k), accumulated retirement accounts, and is now five years away from leaving the workforce. At that point, the conversation needs to become much broader than which investments to own.

What Is the Difference Between Investment Management and Financial Planning?

Investment management focuses primarily on how your money is invested. Financial planning examines your broader financial life and develops a strategy for using your resources to accomplish your goals.

Both are important, and they often work together. The difference is the scope of the questions being asked and the decisions being addressed.

What Does an Investment Manager Actually Do?

An investment manager generally helps determine how your portfolio should be invested based on your objectives, risk tolerance, and time horizon. Depending on the services agreed upon, that may include selecting investments, maintaining an appropriate mix of stocks and bonds, rebalancing, managing investment-related taxes, and monitoring the portfolio over time.

That work matters. An investment strategy should reflect when you will need your money, how much risk you can reasonably take, and what you are trying to accomplish.

But a well-managed portfolio does not automatically answer every question surrounding retirement. Your investments could be appropriate for your risk tolerance while important decisions about Social Security, taxes, healthcare, and retirement income have yet to be addressed.

What Does a Comprehensive Financial Planner Do?

A comprehensive financial planner looks beyond individual investment accounts and examines how different financial decisions affect one another. That often means starting with your goals, income, expenses, family circumstances, and the decisions you expect to face over the next several years.

For someone approaching retirement, financial planning may include:

  • Determining when retirement may be financially feasible.

  • Evaluating Social Security claiming strategies for you and your spouse.

  • Building a retirement income and withdrawal strategy.

  • Reviewing Roth conversion opportunities and their potential tax consequences.

  • Considering how retirement income may affect Medicare premiums.

  • Reviewing insurance coverage and healthcare expenses.

  • Evaluating estate documents, beneficiary designations, and inheritance goals.

  • Developing an investment strategy that supports the retirement plan.

  • Reviewing the plan as your circumstances, tax rules, and priorities change.

The goal is to understand how these decisions fit together. A recommendation that makes sense when looking at one investment account may need to change once taxes, income needs, and other financial circumstances are considered.

Why Does This Difference Matter So Much When You Are Approaching Retirement?

For most of your working life, the basic process of building wealth is relatively straightforward. You earn money, save a portion of it, invest that money, and continue contributing over time.

Retirement changes the questions. Instead of asking how much you should save, you begin asking how much you can reasonably spend, where that income should come from, and how to manage the risks that could affect your plan.

Imagine a couple in The Woodlands who are three years away from retirement. They have accumulated money in two 401(k)s, a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA, and a taxable brokerage account. Their investments may be managed appropriately, but that alone does not establish when they should claim Social Security, which accounts should fund retirement spending, or whether they should consider Roth conversions.

Those are financial planning questions. And the answers can influence how the investment portfolio should be managed in the first place.

How Do You Turn Retirement Savings Into Retirement Income?

This is one of the biggest transitions I work through with people approaching retirement. They have spent decades saving and investing, but now they need a strategy for turning those accumulated assets into income they can actually live on.

We need to understand what their retirement will cost, how much income will come from Social Security or pensions, and how much will need to come from investments. Then we can evaluate how to structure withdrawals, maintain appropriate reserves, and respond if markets perform poorly early in retirement.

For some retirees, keeping several years of anticipated portfolio withdrawals in cash, CDs, or shorter-term fixed-income investments may be worth considering. Others may have enough dependable income from Social Security, pensions, or other sources that a smaller reserve makes sense.

Neither approach is appropriate for everyone. The amount of cash and the investment allocation should be based on the person's spending needs, income sources, liquidity requirements, and tolerance for risk.

This is where comprehensive financial planning becomes particularly useful. Instead of starting with an investment portfolio and figuring out how to make retirement work around it, we can develop the retirement plan and evaluate how the investments should support it.

Can Your Investment Portfolio Be Performing Well While Your Financial Plan Is Missing Something?

Absolutely. A portfolio can be doing exactly what it was designed to do while important financial planning opportunities remain unexplored.

Consider a hypothetical retiree who has an IRA managed by an investment advisor. The investments are being monitored, the portfolio is diversified, and the retiree has sufficient income from Social Security and a pension to cover most regular expenses.

That retiree might also be taking required minimum distributions from the IRA and giving money to charity every year. The investment portfolio could be managed appropriately while the retiree has never discussed whether a qualified charitable distribution might fit their circumstances.

Under IRS Publication 590-B, Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs), eligible IRA owners who are at least age 70½ may be able to make qualified charitable distributions directly to eligible charities. When the applicable requirements are met, these distributions can receive favorable tax treatment and may count toward the individual's required minimum distribution.

That does not mean a qualified charitable distribution is appropriate for every retiree. It means that understanding someone's charitable goals, income sources, age, and tax situation can reveal planning questions that would not necessarily come up during a portfolio review.

The same applies to Social Security decisions, Roth conversions, retirement withdrawal strategies, and estate planning. These topics involve more than investment selection, and they deserve attention when they are relevant to the client's circumstances.

Does Financial Planning Include Tax Planning?

In my view, tax planning should be part of a comprehensive financial plan, particularly for people approaching or already in retirement. Many of the decisions retirees make about investments and income can also affect their taxes.

For example, a Roth conversion may be worth evaluating during years when taxable income is lower. However, converting money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA generally creates taxable income, as explained in IRS Publication 590-B.

That means a Roth conversion should not be evaluated solely by looking at the investments involved. The timing, size of the conversion, current and future tax circumstances, and potential effects on Medicare premiums all deserve consideration.

Tax preparation and tax planning also serve different purposes. Preparing a tax return generally involves reporting what already happened, while tax planning involves evaluating decisions before they are made and considering their potential consequences.

At Tiverton Wealth, we emphasize coordinating retirement, investment, and tax planning so these conversations are considered together. Eligible clients may also receive tax preparation through Tiverton Tax, LLC, a separate affiliated company under common ownership, pursuant to a separate engagement agreement.

Does Working With a Fiduciary Financial Advisor Mean You Automatically Receive Comprehensive Planning?

No. Being a fiduciary and providing comprehensive financial planning are related concepts, but they are not the same thing. An advisor may owe fiduciary duties while providing a limited scope of investment advisory services.

Under the SEC's Commission Interpretation Regarding Standard of Conduct for Investment Advisers, Investment Advisers Act Release No. IA-5248, investment advisers owe fiduciary duties of care and loyalty, with the obligations applying in the context of the advisory relationship and the services undertaken.

Separately, the CFP Board's Code of Ethics and Standards of Conduct, Standard A.1, requires CFP® professionals to act as fiduciaries whenever they provide financial advice to a client. These standards are important, but consumers should still understand what services their advisor has agreed to provide.

If your agreement covers investment management, you should not automatically assume it includes detailed retirement income planning, tax planning, estate coordination, or insurance analysis. Ask what is included, how often those subjects will be reviewed, and whether additional fees apply.

How Is a Flat-Fee Financial Planner Different From an Advisor Who Charges a Percentage of Assets?

One of the reasons I started Tiverton Wealth was that I wanted to provide comprehensive financial planning without calculating my fee as a percentage of the assets a client had accumulated. I wanted the fee to reflect the planning work and level of service involved.

Under a traditional assets-under-management fee arrangement, the advisory fee is generally calculated as a percentage of the assets covered by the agreement. Under a flat-fee arrangement, the advisor charges a stated dollar amount, although the fee may vary depending on the services and complexity of the engagement.

Neither compensation structure, by itself, tells you whether an advisor provides comprehensive financial planning. Some percentage-based advisors provide extensive planning, while some flat-fee advisors focus on narrower services. The important questions are what you receive, how the advisor is compensated, and whether the arrangement fits your needs.

Why Did I Choose a Flat-Fee Model?

I do not believe someone's advisory fee should automatically increase simply because their investment portfolio grows. If someone has accumulated $2 million and another person has accumulated $4 million, that difference alone does not necessarily mean the second person needs twice as much financial planning work.

Their situations may be very different, of course. One person might have several businesses, complicated tax issues, and a substantial estate, while another has relatively straightforward retirement income and investment needs.

That is why Tiverton Wealth uses a flat-fee pricing structure based on the scope and complexity of the engagement. We are a fee-only Registered Investment Advisor, which means our advisory compensation comes from clients rather than commissions from selling investment or insurance products.

Our ongoing services can include comprehensive financial planning and investment management for a stated flat fee. The specific services and fee are described in the client's written advisory agreement, and clients should also consider any applicable investment, custodial, or other third-party expenses.

What Does Comprehensive Financial Planning Look Like at Tiverton Wealth?

When someone comes to me for financial planning, I do not want our first conversation to be entirely about their investment portfolio. I want to understand when they want to retire, what they want retirement to look like, how much they expect to spend, and what financial concerns are keeping them up at night.

From there, we organize our work around six areas of financial planning:

  • Income: Understanding cash flow, spending, savings, and future retirement income sources.

  • Insurance and Risk: Reviewing potential financial risks and existing coverage.

  • Taxes: Evaluating tax-sensitive decisions and coordinating tax planning.

  • Investments: Building and managing an investment strategy around the broader plan.

  • Retirement: Evaluating retirement timing, income sustainability, withdrawals, and changing spending needs.

  • Estate Planning: Reviewing beneficiaries, estate planning goals, and coordination with qualified legal professionals.

We generally present the financial plan over two meetings, allowing time to review each area and discuss the recommendations. We then work through implementation and determine what ongoing planning support makes sense.

You can read more about our financial planning process at Tiverton Wealth, including how we move from the initial discovery meeting to implementing a client's plan.

How Can You Tell If You Are Receiving Investment Management or Comprehensive Financial Planning?

If you already work with a financial advisor, I would not suggest changing advisors simply because you have never seen a formal financial plan. Your advisor may already be helping with these issues, and some planning relationships are less formal than others.

Instead, I would start by asking a few questions:

  • Have we discussed when I can reasonably retire and what that retirement may cost?

  • Have we reviewed when my spouse and I should consider claiming Social Security?

  • Do we have a strategy for which accounts to draw from during retirement?

  • Have we evaluated potential Roth conversions and future required minimum distributions?

  • Have we reviewed how investment withdrawals could affect our taxes and Medicare premiums?

  • Does my investment allocation reflect my actual retirement spending needs?

  • Have we reviewed beneficiaries, estate documents, and insurance coverage?

  • Will we revisit the financial plan regularly as circumstances change?

  • Which of these services are included in my current advisory fee?

If these topics are already being addressed, that is useful information about the scope of your current relationship. If several have never come up, it may be worth asking your advisor whether additional financial planning services are available.

You can also work with a financial planner specifically for planning advice while keeping some or all of your investments elsewhere, depending on the services offered. The right arrangement depends on how much help you need and whether you prefer to manage investments yourself.

Is It Worth Paying for Financial Planning If You Already Know How to Invest?

For some people, it may be. You can be perfectly comfortable choosing investments and still want another professional to help evaluate retirement timing, taxes, withdrawal strategies, or major financial decisions.

In fact, some of the people who may benefit from financial planning are already confident investors. They understand their accounts and have developed disciplined saving habits, but they want help making decisions as they transition from accumulating money to using it.

Other people may prefer a relationship that combines financial planning with ongoing investment management. Both approaches can be reasonable, depending on the person's circumstances, preferences, and needs.

At Tiverton Wealth, our focus is on helping clients coordinate the different parts of their financial lives through a fee-only, flat-fee planning relationship. We also provide investment management as part of applicable ongoing engagements, so the investment strategy can be reviewed alongside the financial plan.

You can learn more about Alex Bridges and his background as a financial planner, or review some of the frequently asked questions about working with Tiverton Wealth.

What Should You Do If You Think You Need More Than Investment Management?

Start by reviewing your current advisory agreement and asking what planning services are included. If your advisor already provides comprehensive planning, you may simply need to schedule a deeper discussion about the decisions you have coming up.

If your relationship is limited to investment management, consider whether a separate financial planning engagement would be useful. You do not necessarily need to move your investments to begin evaluating retirement income, taxes, estate planning, and other financial decisions.

For retirees and pre-retirees in The Woodlands, Conroe, Spring, and the Greater Houston area, Tiverton Wealth provides fiduciary financial planning and investment management through a fee-only, flat-fee model. Our office is located at 2001 Timberloch Place #500 The Woodlands, TX 77380, and we also work with clients remotely where properly registered or exempt from registration.

If you want to understand how that approach works, you can learn more about Tiverton Wealth and our planning philosophy, or visit tivertonwealth.com. You can also contact the firm at 281-865-8858 or alex@tivertonwealth.com to discuss whether our services fit your situation.

My name is Alex Bridges, CFP®, EA, ChFC®, RICP®, and I am the founder and financial planner at Tiverton Wealth, LLC. You can review my full regulatory background on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure website: Alex Bridges — IAPD record.

This article is provided by Tiverton Wealth, LLC for general educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute personalized investment, tax, or legal advice, and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice from a qualified professional familiar with your specific circumstances. Tiverton Wealth, LLC is a fee-only Registered Investment Advisor providing services only in jurisdictions where it is properly registered or exempt from registration. Investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal, and no strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Please consult with a qualified financial, tax, or legal professional before making decisions based on this content.

Frequently Asked Questions About Financial Planning and Investment Management

Is investment management the same as financial planning?

No. Investment management primarily focuses on selecting, managing, and monitoring investments based on your goals and risk tolerance. Comprehensive financial planning examines a broader range of issues, including retirement income, taxes, insurance, estate planning, cash flow, and investments.

Many advisors offer both services, but the specific scope of each advisory relationship should be confirmed.

Do I need a financial planner if I already have an investment advisor?

Not necessarily. Some investment advisors already provide comprehensive financial planning as part of their services. If yours primarily manages your portfolio, an additional financial planning engagement may help you evaluate retirement income, tax considerations, and other decisions that fall outside the existing relationship.

What is the difference between a fee-only advisor and a flat-fee advisor?

Fee-only describes how an advisor is compensated, generally through fees paid by clients rather than product sales commissions. Flat fee describes a specific way those fees are calculated, using a stated dollar amount instead of a percentage of assets.

Tiverton Wealth is both fee-only and flat-fee, with its advisory fees determined by the scope and complexity of the engagement. You can review how Tiverton Wealth charges for financial planning for more information.

Can a financial planner help with retirement taxes and Roth conversions?

Financial planners who offer tax planning services can help evaluate the potential tax consequences of retirement withdrawals, Roth conversions, and other retirement decisions.

IRS Publication 590-B explains that traditional IRA amounts converted to Roth IRAs generally may be included in taxable income, subject to applicable rules. Whether a conversion makes sense depends on individual circumstances and should be reviewed with a qualified professional.

Can I work with a flat-fee financial planner without transferring all my investments?

Yes, depending on the firm and the scope of services offered. Some flat-fee advisors provide standalone planning advice, while others combine planning with investment management.

Tiverton Wealth offers an initial financial planning engagement and ongoing flat-fee services, with the applicable scope and fees described in its written advisory agreement. You can learn more about how our planning process works.

Found this useful? Pass it on.

About the author

Alex Bridges

Tiverton Wealth & Tiverton Tax

Keep reading

Related articles

3 more